Longitudinal study with 171 participants
Since the beginning of the pandemic, voluntary participants from the staff at the University Hospital rechts der Isar at risk of infection participated in the study and were regularly tested. The researchers identified individuals who had contracted SARS-CoV-2 during the first wave of the pandemic in spring 2020, and compared them to a second group of people who had not been infected. Subsequently, both groups were offered vaccination with the mRNA-based Covid-19 vaccine from BioNTech/Pfizer and were monitored for almost two years. The cohort comprised 98 recovered persons and 73 persons without prior infection.
“This longitudinal study is particularly exciting, because we can follow how the immune response evolves over time against the virus and after vaccination” says Professor Knolle, pointing to a study by the team, which has just appeared in Nature Communications. In the new study the team now defined several parameters in the blood of study participants: the concentration of antibodies to the viral spike protein, the binding strength of these antibodies, and their ability to neutralize infection of SARS-CoV-2 variants in cell culture. For estimating the extent of protective immunity, the latter two parameters are particularly important. The study revealed that the ability of the immune system to neutralize the virus correlates only weakly with the antibody titer. Rather, it was critical how effectively these antibodies bind to the virus and thus disable infection.
As predicted from its many mutations, Omicron exhibited the most pronounced evasion from neutralizing antibodies compared to all other viral variants tested. “For Omicron, you need considerably more and better antibodies to prevent infection” points out Professor Keppler. The researchers developed a new virus neutralization test, which allowed them to analyze antibodies in many serum samples and different variants of the virus at high throughput rates. Professor Protzer adds: “A new finding of our study is that people require three separate exposures to the spike protein to build up high-level neutralizing activity against all viral variants, including Omicron.”
As the scientists report, various constellations are possible for these three spike encounters. Triple-vaccinated people without prior SARS-CoV-2 infection had almost the same titer and quality of neutralizing antibodies against Omicron as vaccinated convalescents or people who had a breakthrough infection with Delta or Omicron. Professor Keppler: “In all cases, the neutralization activity reached similarly high levels and this was paralleled by an increased binding strength of the antibodies.” Professor Protzer and Professor Knolle agree: “The immunity built up or strengthened by means of vaccination is key to effective protection against future variants of the virus. A recent breakthrough infection – as irritating and undesirable as it is – has in fact the same effect as an additional vaccination on this important arm of the immune system.”